Key Points
- Julie Allan and Alan Rutherford admitted five wilful-neglect charges involving children in their care.
- Two children were taken to hospital on separate occasions and tested positive for cocaine.
- The Motherwell home was described as uninhabitable, with drug paraphernalia and extensive waste.
- The couple avoided custody but received two years of social-work supervision and nine months of electronic tagging.
- They were ordered to attend addiction services after the court heard the children had been removed into care.
Motherwell (Glasgow Express) November 18, 2026 – Julie Allan and Alan Rutherford have avoided prison after admitting five charges of wilful neglect involving children in their care at a property in Motherwell. Hamilton Sheriff Court heard that two children were taken to hospital on separate occasions and were found to have cocaine in their systems. Sheriff John Hamilton KC imposed two years of social-work supervision, nine months of electronic tagging and attendance at addiction services.
The Scottish Sun reported that Allan, 44, and Rutherford, 47, failed to provide adequate food, care and nutrition and did not properly maintain dental or medical appointments. The children were exposed to unsafe conditions at the property, where the door was not secured against visitors under the influence of drink or drugs.
What did the court hear about the children’s living conditions?
The court heard that concerns were first raised in early 2023 after poor school attendance. When the children attended, they were reportedly dirty and unkempt. Medical examinations identified significant welfare concerns, including dental decay, nappy rash, dirty nails and dandruff.
One child reportedly required 14 teeth to be removed. Health visitors found hypodermic needles at the property and observed evidence that people attended the address to take drugs. Police described the home as uninhabitable, while 17 tonnes of waste were removed from the garden.
Why did two children test positive for cocaine?
Teachers became concerned about the demeanour of two children and arranged for them to receive medical attention. Tests later showed that both had cocaine in their systems on separate occasions. The children recovered, and all five children were taken into care in November 2024.
What sentence did Julie Allan and Alan Rutherford receive?
Sheriff John Hamilton KC placed both defendants, now living at Shields Tower in Motherwell, under social-work supervision for two years. They must attend addiction services and remain subject to electronic tags for nine months, restricting them to their home between 7pm and 7am.
Defence lawyer Ian Scott said Allan’s life had descended into chaotic drug use and described the case as a significant wake-up call. The court heard that she was no longer using illicit substances.
“This was an appalling litany of systemic and prolonged negligence and abuse,” Sheriff John Hamilton KC told the couple. “The important thing is that these children are safe.”
What is the background to the Motherwell neglect case?
The charges covered conduct between January 2023 and November 2024, according to The Scottish Sun. The case involved five children and included failures relating to supervision, nutrition, hygiene, schooling, medical care and home safety. Social-work involvement continued over an extended period before the children were removed from the household. The court’s orders combine supervision, addiction treatment and overnight electronic restrictions rather than immediate imprisonment.
What could the court orders mean for the family’s future?
The children’s removal into care means their immediate safety is being managed outside the household. The two-year supervision order will allow social-work services to monitor Allan and Rutherford while they attend addiction support. The electronic tags will limit their movements overnight for nine months. Any failure to comply with the court’s requirements could lead to further legal consequences, although the available reports do not state that either defendant has breached the orders.
