Key Points
- Conor Erskine told Belfast Coroner’s Court he felt terrified after repeated threats from Fionntán McGarvey.
- Mr Erskine accepted striking the 18-year-old outside the Devenish Complex in Belfast on December 27, 2021.
- Mr McGarvey suffered a fractured skull and brain bleeding before dying in hospital 24 days after the incident.
- A detective said police could not establish why tension developed between the two men.
- The inquest is continuing.
Belfast (Glasgow Express) November 18, 2026 – Conor Erskine told Belfast Coroner’s Court that he felt terrified and believed he had no other option to defend himself before striking 18-year-old Queen’s University student Fionntán McGarvey outside the Devenish Complex in Belfast on December 27, 2021. Mr McGarvey fell and suffered serious head injuries, later dying in hospital after his condition deteriorated. Mr Erskine, giving evidence by videolink from Australia, said repeated threats made him fear for his life. The inquest heard that police have not established the reason for the tension between the two men.
What did Conor Erskine tell the inquest?
As reported by the Belfast Telegraph, Conor Erskine said Mr McGarvey approached him aggressively near the bar during the early hours of December 27, 2021. He said Mr McGarvey repeatedly threatened to assault and kill him, while Mr Erskine repeatedly responded that they should not fight.
Mr Erskine said he offered to move away from the crowd to defuse the situation. He told the inquest that he saw what he interpreted as an incoming threat and reacted instinctively by raising his right arm in an upward swiping movement.
“I saw an incoming threat, and with the threats made before, I was fearful for my life, so instinctively I reacted and threw my arm up,” Mr Erskine told the court.
He accepted that he struck Mr McGarvey but said he did not believe the blow had enough force to cause serious injury. He said he believed the fall and impact with the ground caused the damage.
What happened after the blow?
The Belfast Telegraph reported that Mr Erskine said he immediately tried to help Mr McGarvey after seeing him on the ground. He said he saw blood and called for assistance before checking for a pulse.
Witness Michelle Craig previously described the scene as panicked. She said Mr McGarvey was lying on his back with blood coming from his ear, while Mr Erskine appeared shocked and stressed.
Mr McGarvey sustained a fractured skull and a blood clot on the surface of his brain. He was discharged from hospital eight days after the incident but suffered a further brain bleed a week later. His condition deteriorated and he died in hospital 24 days after the altercation.
What did police tell the coroner?
A detective chief inspector who initially led the investigation told the inquest that officers interviewed witnesses and considered several theories about the source of the tension. However, police were unable to clarify why the confrontation developed.
The inquest also heard that officers could not obtain closed-circuit television footage from the railway halt operated by Translink.
Earlier evidence indicated that the medical treatment Mr McGarvey received was considered appropriate. A pathologist said it was possible the later brain bleed was connected to the original injuries, although this could not be stated categorically from the post-mortem examination alone.
What is the background to the Belfast inquest?
Fionntán McGarvey was an 18-year-old Queen’s University student and talented sportsman. The confrontation occurred outside the Devenish Complex on Finaghy Road North during the early hours of December 27, 2021. Mr Erskine had attended the Down Royal Races before going to the venue and said he had been drinking. The inquest opened at Belfast Coroner’s Court after Mr McGarvey died more than three weeks after the incident.
How could the evidence affect the people involved?
The continuing inquest may help establish the circumstances surrounding the confrontation, the force used, and the medical consequences of Mr McGarvey’s fall. Mr Erskine’s account provides the coroner with his explanation that he acted in self-defence after repeated threats. The McGarvey family continues to hear evidence about the events leading to the death, while the coroner has acknowledged the family’s difficulty during the proceedings. No final findings have been reported, and the case continues.
